• IMA sites
  • IMAJ services
  • IMA journals
  • Follow us
  • Alternate Text Alternate Text
עמוד בית
Tue, 17.11.26

Search results


November 2026
Moshe Y. Flugelman MD, Arieh Riskin MD PhD

Clinical reasoning, the cognitive process by which physicians gather, interpret, and synthesize information to reach diagnostic and therapeutic decisions, is the cornerstone of medical practice. However, it is rarely taught explicitly in medical curricula and the consequences of this omission are substantial. In this narrative review, we integrate theoretical models of clinical cognition, the history and limitations of evidence-based guidelines, and emerging data on artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted clinical reasoning. Clinical reasoning operates through dual cognitive pathways: rapid, pattern-based System 1 and deliberate, analytical System 2 thinking.

This thinking is vulnerable to well-characterized cognitive biases responsible for most diagnostic errors. Guidelines, while representing a systematic approach to codifying evidence, carry inherent limitations when applied to individual patients. Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate diagnostic capabilities comparable to experienced clinicians in structured settings; however, they introduce new risks including automation bias and hallucination. The medical interview remains the foundational act of clinical reasoning and the primary vehicle for building the therapeutic trust that underpins all clinical decisions. In the era of AI, strong clinical reasoning skills are not diminished in importance; they are indispensable. Situation awareness, the integration of perception, comprehension, and projection, is the cognitive capacity that distinguishes effective clinical decision-making, and it is a capacity that neither algorithms nor guidelines can replace. Formal, longitudinal education in clinical reasoning must become a core component of medical training at all levels.

January 2022
Nissim Arish MD, Ariel Rokach MD MHA, Amir Jarjou'i MD, Naama Bogot MD, Irith Hadas Halperen MD, Maher Deeb MD, Eli Golomb MD, and Gabriel Izbicki MD
August 2014
Matti Eskelinen MD PhD, Tuomas Selander MSc, Pertti Lipponen MD PhD and Petri Juvonen MD PhD

Background: The primary diagnosis of functional dyspepsia (FD) is made on the basis of typical symptoms and by excluding organic gastrointestinal diseases that cause dyspeptic symptoms. However, there is difficulty reaching a diagnosis in FD.

Objectives: To assess the efficiency of the Usefulness Index (UI) test and history-taking in diagnosing FD.

Methods: A study on acute abdominal pain conducted by the World Organizati­on of Gast­roentero­logy Research Committee (OMGE) included 1333 patients presenting with acute abdo­minal pain. The clinical history-taking variables (n=23) for each pa­tient were recorded in detail using a prede­fined structured data collection sheet, and the collected data were compared with the final diagnoses.

Results: The most signifi­cant clinical history-taking variables of FD in univa­riate analysis were risk ratio (RR): location of pain at diagnosis (RR = 5.7), location of initial pain (RR = 6.5), previous similar pain (RR = 4.0), duration of pain (RR = 2.9), previous abdominal surgery (RR = 4.1), previous abdominal diseases (RR = 4.0), and previous indigestion (RR = 3.1). T­he sensi­tivity of the physicians’ initial de­cisi­on in detecting FD was 0.44, speci­fi­city 0.99 and effi­ciency 0.98; UI was 0.19 and RR 195.3. In the stepwise multivariate logistic regression analysis, the independent predictors of FD were the physicians’ initial decision (RR = 266.4), location of initial pain (RR = 3.4), duration of pain (RR = 3.1), previous abdominal surgery (RR = 3.7), previous indigestion (RR = 2.2) and vomiting (RR = 2.0).

Conclusions: The patients with upper abdominal pain initially and a previous history of abdominal surgery and indigestion tended to be at risk for FD. In these patients the UI test could help the clinician differentiate FD from other diagnoses of acute abdominal pain.

Legal Disclaimer: The information contained in this website is provided for informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal or medical advice on any matter.
The IMA is not responsible for and expressly disclaims liability for damages of any kind arising from the use of or reliance on information contained within the site.
© All rights to information on this site are reserved and are the property of the Israeli Medical Association. Privacy policy

2 Twin Towers, 35 Jabotinsky, POB 4292, Ramat Gan 5251108 Israel