IMAJ | volume 28
Journal 11, November 2026
pages: 730-735
Summary
Clinical decisions are influenced by how physicians represent uncertainty, interpret disagreement, combine assessments, and evaluate new evidence. These psychological processes can support effective decisions, but they can also cause plausible alternatives to be overlooked or discounted. In this conceptual framework, the author developed a different conceptual framework that brought together findings from cognitive and social psychology, linking them through how clinicians considered alternative explanations and judgments.
Support theory explains why possibilities receive different probability estimates depending on whether they are explicitly named or left unspecified. Naïve realism, the experience of one’s own judgments as objective reflections of reality, helps explain why clinicians may dismiss disagreement rather than examine its basis. Research on collaboration within dyads shows how independently formed assessments can be integrated, whereas groupthink illustrates how pressure for consensus may suppress alternative views. Biased assimilation explains how prior commitments can influence the evaluation of subsequent evidence.