IMAJ | volume 28
Journal 11, November 2026
pages: 701-708
1 Mays Business School, Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas, USA
2 Department of Neonatology, Bnai Zion Medical Center, Haifa, Israel
3 Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Technion–Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel
Summary
Metacognition, which is the capacity to monitor, evaluate, and regulate one’s own cognitive processes, is an important determinant of clinical decision quality. Clinicians who fail to monitor their reasoning are more susceptible to the systematic cognitive biases that contribute to many diagnostic errors. In this narrative review, we integrated theoretical models of metacognition, presented research on intuitive and analytical clinical reasoning, showed empirical studies of cognitive bias in medicine, and described educational interventions targeting metacognitive skills. The review is built on the monitoring–control framework in which monitoring is what clinicians notice about their own reasoning and control is what they do in response. Two monitoring signals are most directly relevant to diagnosis: confidence, which is often poorly calibrated to actual accuracy, and the feeling of rightness, which determines whether an initial diagnosis is reconsidered. Using clinical examples of anchoring, premature closure, availability bias, overconfidence, and confirmation bias, we specified what the clinician needed to monitor and the control action for each bias.
We described a diagnostic time-out, an active search for disconfirming evidence, a discriminating test, or consultation, that monitoring should have triggered. Structured reflection and calibration feedback have shown benefit, whereas bias education alone has shown limited effect on diagnostic accuracy. Metacognitive capacity is a modifiable, teachable competency. Its development is a patient safety imperative, and medical education programs should incorporate explicit metacognitive training, which are linked to concrete clinical cues and actions, as a core component of clinical reasoning curricula.