Israel Medical Association Journal

The Lancet Commission on Medicine, Nazism and the Holocaust was published in November 2023, recognized the potential dangers for the medical profession that are echoed in this history. The tragic events on 7 October 2023 have revealed just how timely and important the Commission's publication is and have raised the question of the relevance to the Holocaust to this attack. One of the continuities from this past and which has dangerous implications for current medicine, is antisemitism. Examination of the antisemitism inherent to medical education in Nazi Germany raises the question of antisemitism in current academia. Since October 7th there has been a drastic rise in antisemitism and antisemitic actions in both the academy and in medicine. We have seen outright refusal to condemn the brutal perpetrators of the October 7th massacre and continue to observe explicit support for the perpetrators from both faculty and students. Medicine, a profession whose foundational tenet is the well being of humanity–all humanity–and that hallows moral clarity, cannot allow for antisemitic speech and actions to exist within the profession. Awareness and education on this history is crucial for the medical profession so that the tragic events of the past do not happen again.

Since the horrific terrorist attacks of 7 October 2023 in Israel perpetrated by the Hamas terrorist group and the ensuing Iron Swords war, there has been another war raging in prominent medical journals in the form of editorials and letters to the editor. Multiple publications filled with misinformation and propaganda have questioned Israel’s right to defend herself, have implicitly or explicitly provided justification for the terror, and have even questioned the legitimacy of Israel’s existence. Rather than serve as a source of frustration and despondency due to abandonment by our colleagues, we believe this situation should serve as a call to action. Israeli physicians cannot afford to passively cede the arena of political advocacy to parties with anti-Israel and even antisemitic bias. Doing so would be devastating to Israeli medicine and to the quality of care we deliver to our patients.

It is common knowledge that in addition to the slaughter of millions of innocent civilians, Nazism caused direct damage to patient care by euthanasia of the handicapped, gruesome human experimentation, and ethnic cleansing of German medical schools. In gastroenterology, 53 prominent academicians living in Nazi-occupied Europe were persecuted by the Nazis. Prior studies analyzed this persecution as it related to gastroenterologists rather than to patient care. What is not known, however, is that Nazi persecution led to a delay of more than one generation in the clinical application of major inventions by these gastroenterologists. These included flexible fiberoptic endoscopy, which was delayed from 1930 to 1957. Fiberoptic transmission was invented by Heinrich Lamm in 1930. Lamm was exiled from Nazi Germany in 1936, and this technique was clinically applied to endoscopy by Hirschowitz only in 1957. Another innovation was fecal occult blood testing for early colon cancer detection, which was devised by Ismar Boas before 1938. Boas committed suicide under Nazi oppression in 1938 and this modality was clinically applied by Greegor only in 1967. The acceptance of refugees from Nazi Germany or Austria into America or into the future State of Israel helped mitigate some of this damage. For example, eight eminent academic gastroenterologists who fled Nazi-occupied countries to then mandatory Palestine made major contributions to the development of academic gastroenterology in the soon-to-be established State of Israel.